Engagement Rings

Looking for ideas as your get ready to pop the question? Discover a collection of non traditional engagement rings and promise rings perfect for gifting to a man or woman. Handmade from resin and high quality nickel free silver finish ring bands, these rings make a unique jewelry gift for your boyfriend, girlfriend, or fiance as a way to express your love and commitment in a novel and fun way. Every ring comes in a sleek black and velvet lined ring gift box. Available in red, green, purple, blue and black colors.

Let customers speak for us

from 1043 reviews
Pizza Glam at its best!

Aubree is so awesome! I asked yet another pair of custom earrings and of course she through and put together my vision of having pizza glam earrings! This is my 11th pair of earrings from Fatally Feminine and of course, I plan to buy more! Look no further for cute, fun, and functional jewelry! No matter what outfit I’m wearing…Fatally Feminine always has something to tie everything together and these custom pizza earrings are just the thing I needed! Already picking out more jewelry to add to my collection 🥰

Linsey Park
Custom order for Linsey
Custom order for Linsey

Really the cutest I'm so happy with my order and love this shop! Packaged and shipped with care. Would order again!

Maggie Havranek
Bright Pastel Rainbow Faux Candy Choker Necklace - Custom Sizes - Handmade Fatally Feminine
Bright Pastel Rainbow Faux Candy Choker Necklace - Custom Sizes - Handmade Fatally Feminine

Really the cutest I'm so happy with my order and love this shop! Packaged and shipped with care. Would order again!

Maggie Havranek
Macaron Heart Necklace - Pink, Purple or Mint Green - Valentines Day Necklace
Macaron Heart Necklace - Pink, Purple or Mint Green - Valentines Day Necklace

Really the cutest I'm so happy with my order and love this shop! Packaged and shipped with care. Would order again!

Maggie Havranek
Bow and Pearl Macaron Heart Earrings - Valentines Day
Bow and Pearl Macaron Heart Earrings - Valentines Day

Really the cutest I'm so happy with my order and love this shop! Packaged and shipped with care. Would order again!

Maggie Havranek
Bright Pastel Rainbow Faux Candy Bracelet - Multiple Sizes - Handmade Fatally Feminine
Bright Pastel Rainbow Faux Candy Bracelet - Multiple Sizes - Handmade Fatally Feminine

Really the cutest I'm so happy with my order and love this shop! Packaged and shipped with care. Would order again!

Maggie Havranek
Pastel Heart Macaron Ring - Adjustable - Valentine's Day
Pastel Heart Macaron Ring - Adjustable - Valentine's Day

Beautifully made, I can’t wait to wear it for my birthday or whenever I feel like it!! 🥳🎂

Chelsea Arispe
Pink Birthday Cake Ring
Pink Birthday Cake Ring

Thanks for the fast shipping! These turned out perfectly. I am so pleased. You are very talented!

Anya
Rainbow Cotton Candy Charm
Rainbow Cotton Candy Charm

Omg!!! Absolutely beautiful necklace!
Must get now!!
They had a similar necklace on TT for $100!
This one is a lot better 🩷🧡💛🩵

Kathleen
Pastel Faux Candy Necklace - Custom Length
Pastel Faux Candy Necklace - Custom Length
Beautiful Jewelry!

My second time getting items from this shop! Just so cute !! Wore this set for Easter .

Kassandra Argote
Chocolate Bunny Easter Dangle Earrings, Bow Charm, Handmade in Resin by Fatally Feminine
Chocolate Bunny Easter Dangle Earrings, Bow Charm, Handmade in Resin by Fatally Feminine

Buying another one because the first one was so cute! I’ve been looking for mock candy necklaces since I first wore a candy necklace as a kid. Love this necklace so much ❤️

Daphne
Bright Pastel Rainbow Faux Candy Choker Necklace - Custom Sizes - Handmade Fatally Feminine
Bright Pastel Rainbow Faux Candy Choker Necklace - Custom Sizes - Handmade Fatally Feminine

Not only is the item as described…the seller was super fast and I was pleasantly surprised to get my earrings before V-day! It ties together my outfit perfectly AND the earrings are lightweight!

Linsey Park
Bow Candy Heart Statement Earrings - Multiple Colors - Handmade in the USA by Fatally Feminine
Bow Candy Heart Statement Earrings - Multiple Colors - Handmade in the USA by Fatally Feminine
I LOVE them

These earrings are so lovely. Perfect for the season or just celebrating love.

Her Fierceness
Pink Sparkle Heart Drop Earrings, Valentine's Charm Jewelry, Handmade Clay Statement Earring
Pink Sparkle Heart Drop Earrings, Valentine's Charm Jewelry, Handmade Clay Statement Earring

This item is sooooo adorable and well made. I can’t wait to wear it.

Erin Lewis
Sweet Heart Statement Necklace, Valentine's Charm Jewelry, Gold or Silver Adjustable Length
Sweet Heart Statement Necklace, Valentine's Charm Jewelry, Gold or Silver Adjustable Length

High quality great item thank you

Pepito
Faux Candy Bracelet - Custom Name Bracelet
Faux Candy Bracelet - Custom Name Bracelet